Rep Martin David Kiar, Two Thumbs Up!
Here is a letter from Beth N. to her Rep, David Kiar, who is another legislator who has some good sense when it comes to HB101.
—–Original Message—–
From: Beth N.
Sent: Tuesday, March 25, 2008 12:41 PM
To: Kiar, Martin
Subject: From ‘Write Your Representative’ Website
To the Honorable Martin David Kiar;
I am writing to you because I am very concerned about HB 101. I strongly disagree with Rep. Thurston’s belief that banning certain dog breeds will curb dangerous dog behavior. It doesn’t make sense to cull the canine poplulation to eliminate thousands of wonderful pets just because of the behavior and lack of pet-ownership responsibility of some dog owners. Perhaps we should be looking at stronger pet owning licensing requirements & accountability; however, eliminating non-aggressive animals just because they were born a specific breed is cruel, unjust and ineffective. Get to the source - train the people & hold them accountable. Have breeding of dogs restricted, and encourage spay & neuter programs & dog training/dog behavior education. Dog is man’s best friend - let’s show them some respect.
Sincerely,
Beth N
——————
Beth’s representative took the time to write and send her a personal response.
—– Original Message —–
From: “Kiar, Martin” <Martin.Kiar@myfloridahouse.gov>
To: Beth N
Sent: Tuesday, March 25, 2008 12:48 PM
Subject: RE: From ‘Write Your Representative’ Website
Thank you for your email. I agree with you completely and I will absolutely oppose HB 101. It is a bad and unfair bill. Have a great day.
Take care,
Martin David Kiar
Representative Martin David Kiar, District 97
6600 University Drive
Parkland, FL 33067
954-346-2813
Fax 954-346-2815
Misquoted
It seems the press really is notorious for changing a quote to fit what they want to portray. I found a condensed article from the original Sun-Sentinel article today. This one was on the on-line Herald Tribune site.
And as it was written:
Helen Schwarzmann, of the Florida Doberman Pinscher Rescue Ring, started a blog on her group’s Web site opposing the bill. Any breed can attack a human, she said. Labrador retrievers, the most popular breed in America, rank near the top in reported cases of dog bites in South Florida, she said.
I NEVER said “Any breed can attack a human.”
This was the original quote from the Sun-Sentinel article:
Fort Lauderdale’s Helen Schwarzmann, of the Florida Doberman Pinscher Rescue Ring, started a blog on her group’s Web site to try to derail the bill. Thurston’s move to target certain breeds places the blame on the dogs, she said, instead of where it should be: their owners.
“Any breed can go out and do bad things,” Schwarzmann said, noting that Labrador retrievers, the most popular breed in America, rank near the top in reported cases of dog bites in South Florida.
—-
As you can see, I never used those misquoted words. By “bad things,” I was referring to mischief, not necessarily attacking humans.
It’s appalling how someone can recreate a quote to suit his/her needs.
Meanwhile, please keep your letters going to your representatives. Let them know you want to keep your dogs no matter where in Florida you live.
Please Watch This Video - Michael Vick’s Rehabbed Pit Bulls
This is a warm story about Pit Bulls and how they can love and be loved.
What an amazing segment.
If you are as moved by this as I was, please send the link to your representatives and let them see the other side of Pit Bulls.
Press Inquiries
For Press inquiries, please contact Jude Piccola.
Cell 239-851-0432
Home phone/fax 239-939-3680
E-mail apic@aol.com
Please forward the links to any articles written about HB101 to dobermannrescue@earthlink.net, and we will post them on the blog.
Thank you,
Helen
South Florida HB101 Articles
Two newspapers in South Florida have run articles on HB101 recently.
PETS AND THE LAW
State proposal to allow dangerous-dog ban stirs debate
By ROBERTO SANTIAGO
Posted on Sat, Mar. 08, 2008
——————
Bill would let Florida cities ban
pit bulls, other dog breeds
|Tallahassee Bureau
- March 16, 2008
Representative Ralph Poppell rocks!
This is Representative Ralph Poppell’s response to my letter.
October 25, 2007
Thank you for your copying me on your recent e-mail, in which you expressed concern with regard to House Bill 101. I am pleased that you took the time to contact me, and I appreciate being able to have the benefit of your views regarding this legislation.
As you know, this proposal was recently referred to the House Committee on Agribusiness, of which I am a member, for review and potential consideration. There is a possibility that, during the Committee process, this legislation could be amended and substantially alter the intent of the language. As such, my staff and I will continue to monitor the proposal for potential changes.
In the interim, however, please know that I feel that it is the owner of the dog that should be responsible for the actions of his or her dog – regardless of the breed. It is not logical to impugn particular breeds of dogs merely because of stereotypes and negative publicity. Simply, pet owners need to be accountable for the behavior of their animals, not the government.
Should this proposal be considered by the Agribusiness Committee, I will be certain to remain mindful of your remarks. Once again, thank you for writing.
Sincerely,
Representative Ralph Poppell
State House District 29
Response to my letter to Governor Crist
Here is the response I received from Governor Crist’s office:
October 18, 2007
Thank you for writing to Governor Charlie Crist to voice your concerns relating to dangerous dogs and the banning of specific breeds of dogs. The Governor appreciated receiving your letter and has asked that I respond on his behalf.
Florida law (Section 767.14) currently prevents local municipalities from crafting a “dangerous dog” ordinance aimed at a specific breed of dog. As you may be aware, there is a bill that has been filed that seeks to change this law. Representative Thurston is sponsoring House Bill 101, which calls for the deletion of language which prevents local municipalities from imposing a ban on specific breeds of dangerous dogs. You may track the progress of this bill through the legislative process by going to the following website: http://www.flsenate.gov/session/index.cfm?BI_Mode=ViewBillInfo&Mode=Bills&SubMenu=1&Year=2008&billnum=101
The Executive Office of the Governor will follow this bill and all other bills as they move through the legislative process. Generally, Governor Crist does not take a position on a specific bill until it has been adopted by the Legislature and presented for his action, as bills can be amended substantially during the legislative process. Please be assured, if final legislation is presented to the Governor on this topic, he will consider your input as he decides whether to sign or veto.
As a final point, you may wish to share your comments with members of your local legislative delegation to express your opposition to this bill and provide them any information which they might use to make a decision on this issue.
Again, thank you for taking the time to share your views with Governor Crist.
Sincerely,
Randy J. Ball, Policy Coordinato
Executive Office of the Governor
Public Safety Unit
RB/mmm
E-mail the AgriBusiness Committee
I e-mailed each Representative on the AgriBusiness committee today. I wish others would do the same to defeat this Bill.This is the e-mail list of those Representatives, including the chair:
bryan.nelson@myfloridahouse.gov, debbie.boyd@myfloridahouse.gov, bill.galvano@myfloridahouse.gov, bill.heller@myfloridahouse.gov, martin.kiar@myfloridahouse.gov, carlos.lopez-cantera@myfloridahouse.gov, ralph.poppell@myfloridahouse.gov , juan.zapata@myfloridahouse.gov, denise.grimsley@myfloridahouse.gov
Denise Grimsley IS the chair, and she answered my e-mail this evening as such:
——-
We have just received the bill and I have not had an opportunity to review. Thank you for bringing this to my attention.
Denise Grimsley
State Representative
District 77
205 South Commerce Avenue, Suite B
Sebring, Fl 33870-3604
863.385.5251
Rep Denise Grimley’s response to my letter
We have just received the bill and I have not had an opportunity to review. Thank you for bringing this to my attention.
Denise Grimsley
State Representative
District 77
205 South Commerce Avenue, Suite B
Sebring, Fl 33870-3604
863.385.5251